U.S. Gold, Going or Completely Gone?
By Rob Kirby
This past Tuesday evening I found myself reading a snippet from Enrico Orlandini’s,DTAnalysis [DT stands for “Dow Theory”] - where Mr. Orlandini opined,
"I believe the [U.S.] trade gap will surprise people and continue to shrink and may even turn positive for the first time in decades. Unfortunately, this will only facilitate the flow out of the US dollar and bond and that’s not a good thing.”
With Enrico being “technically oriented” and me being more fundamentally oriented, I recall how I intuitively did not believe the U.S. Census Bureau’s published U.S. Trade numbers and how I might go about proving that they were falsified:

My primary field of research is focused on precious metals; namely, gold and silver, and I know that recent reports indicate that various countries are contemplating repatriating their sovereign gold reserves. Further, the U.S. Treasury and Federal Reserve have balked atGATA’s recent Freedom of Information [F.O.I] requests and demands for an independent, verifiable audit of the Sovereign U.S. Gold Reserve – thus a little bit of forensic investigation of U.S. gold exports was in order.
I just needed to figure out how to access the relevant numbers.
The United States Geological Survey [USGS] publishes monthly Mineral Industry Surveysdesigned to provide a macro-import/export-overview of the U.S. precious metals [gold] industry. The data in these surveys is supplied to the USGS principally by industry trade groups such as the World Gold Council as well as official sources like the U.S. Census Bureau:

source: USGS Feb. 09 Mineral Industry Survey
I took special note of how 2,920 metric tonnes of “Gold Compounds” had been exported from the U.S. in 2008. This number seemed BIGGER than BIG – because the U.S is only alleged to have stockpiles of sovereign gold of 8,100 metric tonnes while annual U.S. mine production of gold is roughly 228 metric tonnes. This figure of 2,920 metric tonnes is equal to 36 % of all alleged sovereign U.S. gold stocks or more than 14 times annual U.S. gold mine production. So, I was left wondering, “just what is/are ‘gold compounds’?
I contacted the USGS and queried a qualified individual [who had working knowledge of this data stream] about the definition of “Gold Compounds”. I was told that, according to the U.S. Census Bureau – who supplies not only the definition but the actual reported numbers, gold compounds were typified by industrial type products containing low percentages/amounts of actual gold content – like gold paint.
I then reasoned with the USGS person, if such were the case, why would U.S. exports have increased in 2008 to nearly 3,000 metric tonnes [when the Global Economy was slowing and the U.S. Dollar was strong] from 2007, when U.S. exports totaled approximately 2,000 metric tonnes [when the U.S. Dollar was weaker and the Global Economy was booming]? I noted that this was counter-intuitive and made no fundamental economic sense:

source: USGS Feb. 08 U.S. Mineral Industry Survey
When confronted with reason, the individual for the USGS agreed that the data, as published, did not make logical sense and explained that the U.S. Census Bureau was questioned as to the veracity of this particular line item in their data.
I asked the USGS employee if the gross weight or the gross value [not shown in the table but known to the USGS] of the “Gold Compounds” was queried.
The individual confirmed that their query to the U.S. Census Bureau dealt with the gross value being assigned to these exported goods.
I responded rhetorically, “being an issue of gross value – then let me guess that the U.S. Census Bureau is assigning an astronomically high value to these goods. Such a high value would be COMPLETELY INCONSISTENT with what the U.S. Census Bureau claims these items are- namely, industrial goods. The values being reported would be more in line with these goods being gold bullion or equivalents”.
The individual from the USGS confirmed my reasoning when he responded, “that would be CORRECT”.
The Implications
Ladies and gentlemen, the foregoing data and discussion with the USGS individual is proof that the United States of America [or criminal elements within its Treasury and/or The Federal Reserve] “HAS” surreptitiously exported physical gold - and continues to do so. It is confirmed. The exports are likely coin melt [or gold compound, if you prefer] from the great gold confiscation back in 1933; or alternatively, this terminology is being used to disguise physical repatriation of foreign gold bullion formerly on deposit with the N.Y. Federal Reserve. Such repatriations are recorded as “exports” in U.S. Trade data. Public acknowledgement of same would scream like a siren call that the global financial community has totally lost faith in American financial stewardship – hence the need to do so on the sly.
This is being done in a vain/desperate/losing battle to satiate “off the charts” global demand for physical gold bullion arising from the profligacy of the American Empire’s two previous Administrations and to prop up the failing U.S. Dollar.
Over the course of 2007 / 2008 – more than 5,000 metric tonnes of “Gold Compounds” have been exported from the United States of America representing more than 62 % of reported sovereign U.S. gold reserves or about 24 times annual U.S. mine production.
5000 metric tonnes = 160 753 733 troy ounces [$128 billion+ at today’s prices]
The fact that industry funded trade groups like the World Gold Council and other professional gold consultancies, who shall remain nameless, have not reported these facts negates their credibility and illuminates them as dupes or willing shills. These fraudulent or ignorant organizations deserve to be shuttered and disbanded.
U.S. Trade Data Is Bogus
The value of these bullion exports significantly “skew” the doctored U.S. Trade numbers [coincidentally, also prepared by the U.S. Census Bureau] in an attempt to convey a picture that the U.S. financial position is improving.
The reality is this, when gold exports are backed-out, the U.S. Trade picture is decidedly worse.
The United States of America claims to possess a little more than 8,100 metric tonnes of sovereign gold stored principally at Fort Knox, Kentucky, West Point, N.Y., the Denver Mint and The New York Fed. The sovereign U.S. gold reserve has not been independently audited since the 1950’s during the Eisenhower Administration. GATA’s freedom of information requests are all about ensuring that the 8,100 metric tonnes of U.S. sovereign gold is still owned by the U.S.
In April, 2008 the Federal Reserve responded to GATA’s request, releasing hundreds of pages of worthless information with significant portions redacted. They also claimed that they were withholding hundreds of additional pages of documents. The status of the withheld documents is currently under appeal.
These stonewalling tactics – withholding details - are eerily similar to those employed by Messer’s Bernanke, Paulson and Geithner refusing to divulge frank details as to “who” the beneficial recipients were of TARP and TALF funds.
No credible audit of the Sovereign U.S. Gold Reserve will EVER be allowed – because the gold is simply not there.
Hope you have some.
Rob Kirby is proprietor of Kirbyanalytics.com and sales agent for Bullion Custodial Services. Subscribers to the Kirbyanalytics newsletter can look forward to a weekend publication analyzing many recent global geo-political events and more. Subscribe to Kirbyanalytics news letter here. Buy physical gold, silver or platinum bullion here.
end.
As many of you know, this is an area that Reg Howe, Don Jack, and others follow very closely. Generally speaking, the usa when it exports gold, the gold exported comes from the Federal Bank of NY. This bank houses foreign gold or what we term "ear marked' gold. We have been reporting for over 6 years gold leaving usa shores being repatriated to their foreign home.Generally speaking, 100% of ear-marked gold exports are derived from the Bank of NY.
In or around 2003-2005 total foreign gold held by the usa totalled around 6900 tonnes of gold. That total has steadily declined to around 6300 tonnes of gold. For 2008 year, a total of 220 tonnes of ear-marked gold was repatriated to their rightful sovereign holders.
Now, the usa has released export data and for the first time ever, the term "gold compound" was used.
First, a little background information:
The usa is the only country in the world with official gold not of "good delivery" gold. By good delivery we mean .999 gold. In 1933 the usa confiscated gold from its citizenry and then melted down all the coins into bars. They also used the gold coins not sold yet as they too were melted down. The usa gold is of .9000 qualtity. Generally, the rest of the world uses .91 in fineness for gold coins, so the term for coin-melt gold is generally perceived as either .90 gold ( or .8999) or .91 gold. The usa is .90 gold. The usa did not bother to purify the gold on hand to .999 gold, however the true weight of gold was accurate. In other words the total weight of the bar was 110%. If a bar had 100 oz of gold, the total weight of the bar was 110 oz.
In 1937, all of this coin-melt gold entered into its new home, Fort Knox, in Kentucky. The facility took over 3 years to build.
It now looks like the usa is exporting gold, not from the Republic Federal Bank of NY but from Fort Knox itself, the home of coin-melt.
The usa is trying to hide data from all of us as they know we monitor the NY bank regularly. We were quite surprised to see that gold had stopped moving out of usa shores at the conclusion of 2008. We were aware that Germany had wanted its gold back but it was not forthcoming.
From 2007 and 2008, over 5000 tonnes of gold compound was exported from the usa. It was confimed by the Census people that the dollar value was huge. The usa holds a supposed total of 8100 tonnes of gold. It is also clear that export dollars from gold sales have helped the usa in their trade report.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN; GOLD HAS LEFT FORT KNOX. This is why the refiners are working overtime in Europe.
This activity by the usa treasury is criminal. Only an act of congress can authoritze gold sales. I urge you to read and re-read Kirby's paper!!
OK lets go on to my regular commentary:
Gold closed up by 17.60 to 979.00. Silver advanced a further 47 cents to 15.67
The open interest on the gold comex fell by 6000 contracts as some nervous nellies departed the scene. Over on the silver side of things, speculators piled on rising a cool
2000 contracts to 102,000. The longs are comfortable in taking on JPMorgan and HSBC.
The dollar tanked big time yesterday falling a big 1.13 to 79.33. All the energy yesterday was done to prop up two elements of the economy:
1. the bonds
2. the stock market.
As I pointed out to you, the long bond at 116 was a trigger point which would have commenced the melting of derivatives at JPMorgan. The banking community called on its rescue and all printed money was called upon to prop up the bonds and the falling stock market. The long bond rose from 116 to 119.3 and the 10 yr yield fell from 3.75% to around 3.46%. The Dow rose by 96 points.The Dow was even at 3;30 so a patented Hail Mary play drove the dow up. The usa authorities wanted to enter the weekend on a positive note.
The cartel then ran out of printed money and as such, gold rose and the dollar tanked as their was insufficient reserves on hand to prop up the dollar.
This from Ambrose Pritchard-Evans:
By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard
Last Updated: 5:51AM BST 29 May 2009
"We could be nearing the end-game for the US dollar but the Fed has little choice at this point. We're in a vicious circle where any policy aimed at supporting the US economy must be at the expense of the dollar." And: "Beijing is clearly losing its patience with the Fed's policy of printing paper, seen as a form of stealth default. There is some risk that further moves to step up quantitative easing could cause China to boycott US Treasury auctions."
-END-
And now for some economic news:
First quarter GDP sourced badly:
U.S. GDP falls 5.7 pct in Q1
WASHINGTON, May 29 (Reuters) - The U.S. economy contracted slightly less than initially estimated in the first quarter, while corporate profits rebounded, according to a Commerce Department report on Friday that hinted that the recession was moderating.
Gross domestic product, which measures total goods and services output within U.S. borders, dropped at a 5.7 percent annual rate, the department said, less than the 6.1 percent estimated by the government last month.
The revisions were below market expectations for a 5.5 percent contraction for the January-March quarter.
Output has declined for three straight quarters for the first time since 1974-1975.
The Commerce Department's preliminary report also showed corporate profits after taxes increased 1.1 percent in the first quarter, the first increase in a year, after plummeting 10.7 percent in the fourth quarter. Analysts polled by Reuters had forecast profits dropping 7 percent…
-END-
This next number is horrifying..the Chicago Purchasing Managers Index. It plummeted in May from a consensus 42 to 34 signalling the mid-west business activity is falling pretty hard:
09:45 May Chicago Purchasing Manager's Index 34.9 vs. consensus 42.0
Apr reading was 40.1.
* * * * *
U.S. Midwest business activity falls hard in May
CHICAGO, May 29 (Reuters) - Business activity in the U.S. Midwest contracted in May at a much more severe rate than expected, reversing an unexpectedly strong result last month, a report showed on Friday.
The Institute for Supply Management-Chicago business barometer fell to 34.9 in May from 40.1 in April.
Economists had forecast the index at 42.0. A reading below 50 indicates contraction in the regional economy.
The employment component of the index fell to 25.0 from 31.8 in April. New orders slipped to 37.3 from 42.1 but production was steady at 38.1. Prices paid rose to 29.8 from 28.4.
-END-
The Michigan confidence number hardly budged from the previous month:
09:55 May Univ. of Michigan Confidence 68.7 vs. consensus 68.0
Prior reading was 67.9.
end
The Wall Street Journal reports on a surge in mortage rates, somethig that the Obama administration is loathe to hear:
21:33 WSJ discusses the surge in mortgage rates
Citing a survey by HSH Associates, the Journal notes that the average rate for 30-year fixed-rate loans jumped to 5.44% on Thursday, the highest level since early February. The rate was up from 5.29% on Wednesday and 5.03% on Tuesday. The paper adds that higher rates are likely to put more pressure on home prices and sales, citing estimates from Credit Suisse that a 10 bp increase in mortgage rates is equivalent to a 1% increase in home prices. The article goes on to highlight anecdotal evidence surrounding a recent drop off in mortgage applications.
Reference Link (subscription required)
end
Bix Weir comments on the pending GM bankruptcy and what will happen to suppliers. He believes that they too will be forced into receivership. I believe he is correct:
Here's the latest article about auto suppliers about to fail...
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?
pid=20601103&sid=aOh0v_R7K06M&refer=news
Personally, I believe most if not all of the suppliers and auto makers will be forced into bankruptcy due to their inner connectivity.
The reality is that they are ALL needed to produce autos because EVERY part of a car is needed to complete the car for sale from the engine to the ash tray.
Make no mistake, the ramifications of a global auto meltdown are on par with the Banking meltdown. The cascade of defaults will quickly spread to the general economy and especially the banking sector and we are acutely familiar with the fragility on that front.
Far be it for me to be an alarmist but things are about to get VERY ugly so if you have a bunker it's time to dive in!
Bix
PS - It is rumored that the Credit Default Swaps written against GM are in the $Trillions and mostly backed by AIG. No one can verify this because CDS's are private contracts written without a clearing house to track volumes.
end.
The following is a commentary on what the increase in debt is doing to households:
Leap in U.S. debt hits taxpayers with 12% more red ink
By Dennis Cauchon, USA TODAY
Taxpayers are on the hook for an extra $55,000 a household to cover rising federal commitments made just in the past year for retirement benefits, the national debt and other government promises, a USA TODAY analysis shows.
The 12% rise in red ink in 2008 stems from an explosion of federal borrowing during the recession, plus an aging population driving up the costs of Medicare and Social Security.
That's the biggest leap in the long-term burden on taxpayers since a Medicare prescription drug benefit was added in 2003.
The latest increase raises federal obligations to a record $546,668 per household in 2008, according to the USA TODAY analysis. That's quadruple what the average U.S. household owes for all mortgages, car loans, credit cards and other debt combined.
"We have a huge implicit mortgage on every household in America — except, unlike a real mortgage, it's not backed up by a house," says David Walker, former U.S. comptroller general, the government's top auditor.
USA TODAY used federal data to compute all government liabilities, from Treasury bonds to Medicare to military pensions.
Bottom line: The government took on $6.8 trillion in new obligations in 2008, pushing the total owed to a record $63.8 trillion.
The numbers measure what's needed today — set aside in a lump sum, earning interest — to pay benefits that won't be covered by future taxes.
Congress can reduce or increase the burden by changing laws that determine taxes and benefits for programs such as Medicare and Social Security.
Rep. Jim Cooper, D-Tenn., says exploding debt has focused attention on the government's financial challenges. "More and more, people are worried about our fiscal future," he says.
Key federal obligations:
• Social Security. It will grow by 1 million to 2 million beneficiaries a year from 2008 through 2032, up from 500,000 a year in the 1990s, its actuaries say. Average benefit: $12,089 in 2008.
• Medicare. More than 1 million a year will enroll starting in 2011 when the first Baby Boomer turns 65. Average 2008 benefit: $11,018.
•Retirement programs. Congress has not set aside money to pay military and civil servant pensions or health care for retirees. These unfunded obligations have increased an average of $300 billion a year since 2003 and now stand at $5.3 trillion.
-END-
Japan's exports are now starting to rebound as China is demanding such amount of goods to satisify its citizenry:
Japan’s Industrial Production Surges Most in 56 Years
May 29 (Bloomberg) -- Japan’s industrial output surged the most in 56 years in April as a rebound in exports helped the economy emerge from its worst recession since World War II.
Production rose 5.2 percent from March, the second monthly gain, the Trade Ministry said today in Tokyo. The increase was faster than the 3.3 percent economists estimated, and companies said they planned to boost output in May and June as well.
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?
pid=20601087&sid=ahEPo3B.gkfM&refer=home
end.
Chinese citizenry are now hoarding gold like their is no tomorrow:
Gold fever grips Chinese investors
By Wang Ying (China Daily)
Updated: 2009-05-29 09:38
Bitten by the gold bug, Chinese investors are now rushing to hoard the yellow metal as fears over the global recession deepen.
The increased sales of gold bars and gold jewelry in Shanghai, Beijing, Guangzhou and other large cities are reflected in the precious metal's price surge on the Shanghai Gold Exchange (SGE), which trades in gold contracts for forward deliveries. Gold prices quoted on the SGE have increased by an average 6.74 percent in the past month to the current level of about 209 yuan a gram.
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/bizchina/2009-05/29/content_7952537.htm
end.
And now , I will give you my report on the gold delivery for June.
I promised to you that I would have a clearer picture on Friday. I will need Monday's data to give definitive results.
However, as of this weekend, let me give you what we know.
The first day delivery on gold comex was only 151000 oz which is very small. There is also another 1.0 million oz left to be hit.
However there is another figure that is not in the equation yet and that is the options exercised to get a gold comex contract. We know that 38000 option contracts were exercised on Tuesday night.
That represents 3.8 million oz. What we do not know is how many of those rolled into an August contract or how many stayed behind and waited for delivery. We will know Monday afternoon. It could be zero oz up to the entire 3.8 million oz.
Let wait and see and then I will report on its significance.
I wish you all a grand weekend.
Harvey.