http://www.lemetropolecafe.com/
James Joyce table
Good morning Ladies and Gentlemen:
I have forwarded a complaint to the Inspector General of the CFTC regarding the massive fraud in the gold and silver shorts by two unnamed banks in silver and 3 unnamed banks in gold.
You will see correspondence between myself and Ted Butler:
Here is the correspondence and the complaint follows:
Harvey,
That's great. I'll be coming out with more soon
Ted
-----Original Message-----
From: Harvey Organ <harveyorgan@rogers.com>
To: Ted Butler
Cc: don jack <djack@lerners.ca>
Sent: Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:10 pm
Subject: FW: OIG: report fraud, waste and abuse at CFTC..silver and gold massive short.
Hi Ted:
I sent this out a few minutes ago.
Let me know if there is anything I can do for you.
I am committed in exposing this massive fraud.
All the best
Harvey.
From: Harvey Organ [mailto:harveyorgan@rogers.com]
Sent: August-29-08 11:08 PM
To: 'oig@cftc.gov'
Cc: don jack
Subject: OIG: report fraud, waste and abuse at CFTC..silver and gold massive short.
Dear Inspector General:
My name is Harvey Organ and I reside in Toronto Ontario Canada. I have been an investor in silver and gold for over 50 years. I have been an active investor in these two precious metals on the commodity exchange for over 10 years.
Last Friday evening, I received a report from Ted Butler in which data is taken from a monthly report issued by the CFTC called the Bank Participation Report. The relevant data is found in the July and August sections of the report.
The data clearly speaks for themselves. As of July 1.2008 two unnamed US banks were short 30.9 million oz of silver. As of August 5, two USA banks were short 33,805 contracts of comex silver or 169 million oz, an increase of 138 million oz of silver. (5 x increase in 1 month). During this time the price of silver declined from a peak of 19.55 to a low of 12.22 and now trading at 13.60
For gold, three banks held 778000 oz of gold short and by August 5, 3 unnamed usa banks sold short an additional 8.639 million oz of gold or an increase of 7.8 million oz (11 x increase).
In silver the amt sold short equates to an amount greater than the comex inventory and an amount almost equal to the inventory at the SLV in London. The quantity equates to 20% of the production of silver for the entire year.
In gold, the 7.8 million oz represents 11% of the gold production. Gold fell 150.00 during this short raid.
The commissioner always pontificates that the commodity exchange is the discovery mechanism for price and the physical market dictates the price.
Somehow something has gone wrong. We now have massive shortages of metals and the price of these precious metals are down? My jeweller has just informed me that he gets silver at 18.00 per oz for making jewellery. The official price is $13.60. He is paying$ 5.60 over spot whereas before he paid 50 cents above spot.
We were informed yesterday that the biggest refiner in South Africa is out of Krugerrands for the first time in its history. The refiner sells on average 1.15 milllion oz of Krugerrands per year or 5700 oz per day.
They issued a press release to state that a Swiss buyer bought 5000 oz and cleaned them out. You mean to tell me that they keep only 1 days inventory for the world;s most popular investment gold coin.
These physical metals have been in short supply for months. It seems that the massive shorting by these two/three banks certainly caused additional shortfalls unforeseen by the banking cartel.
Mr Inspector General: for some strange reason, the two banks in question , I gather, leased the entire silver supply from the SLV over in England. The reason I state this is because it is the only inventory known to exist on the planet. The comex does not have this quantity of inventory. Somehow a negative 3.5% lease rate per annum was engineered by the bullion banks to these two unnamed banks to carry out their deed. The reason for the leasing of silver was to show the Commissioner that they had silver. The problem of course is that the silver does not belong to the two banks and belongs to the SLV owners for wish for a rise in silver. If they found that the operators leased the entire inventory I can assure you class action law suits will result.
It is obvious that a massive short in both silver and gold caused the fall in price which is contrary to the stated goals of pricing at the CFTC. The Commodity exchange must follow discovery of the pricing mechanism not create the price.
I understand that you are involved in sorting out the mess created by the massive shorting of oil by Sempro and we applaud you efforts in exposing this massive fraud on the public.
With respect to silver and gold, losses of hundreds of billion dollars were lost by small investors only to go to these two or three banks and this is terribly wrong. We must have free markets and not be subjected to manipulation of this sort.
I would like you to explain to me what is the real legitimate business that the two./three banks have for suddenly selling short such huge quantities of speculative instruments over a brief time period?
Do we want banks to be engaged in this type of activity? If the banks cannot cover their shorts, I guess the taxpayers will be called upon again to bail them out of another speculation gone bad!!!
Is this is in the interests of the public?
Do traders who lost money in the recent price collapse of silver and gold have a reason to believe that their money is in the pockets of these two banks? If so do I have recourse?
Mr Chilton wished me luck when I presented the case to him. This is flagrant manipulation identical to the oil situation.
The data on the Bank Participation report is so clear and compelling that it is hard to conclude anything but manipulation. There is no other explanation to cause the price of these metals to fall and stay low and yet both physical metals are scarce and cannot be bought because of their scarcity.
There is now no doubt that foreign entities will seize upon the moment as they are aware of the scarcity and they will pounce upon the last two known physical supplies at the LBMA and Comex.
How will you act if everyone takes delivery and the comex defaults?
Dear Mr Inspector General: please help me to understand how this happened. Markets must be free. It seems that the regulatory agency is responsible for this type of blatant manipulation and they turned a blind eye as it seems that they are feeding from the hand of the banks. I guess they forgot what their mandate really is!!
I thank you for your kind attention and again I applaud your great work in exposing the mess in the oil market.
Sincerely
Harvey B Organ
298 Russell Hill Rd
Toronto Ontario
Canada
Email: harveyorgan@rogers.com
Home phone 416 928 08 98\
There is a lot to tell you this morning.
First gold traded all over the map again on Friday. Gold closed down by 1.10 to 829.70. Silver lowered by 9 cents to 13.58.
Again the open interest diverged with gold Oi rising by 3000 and silver declining by another 2000. Gold’s OI is 385000 and silver is now resting pretty much at its low point of 118000.
Also almost 5000 or 25 million oz are standing. It will take the entire month to clear this quantity.
There are several newsworthy events. The biggest came from the usa regarding spending and income:
U.S. July consumer spending slows, inflation jumps
WASHINGTON, Aug 29 (Reuters) - U.S. personal income tumbled unexpectedly in July and spending slowed as the effects of government stimulus wore off and an inflation measure was at a 17-year high, a government report released on Friday showed.
Personal income fell 0.7 percent in the month, the sharpest decline since a 2.3 percent plunge in August 2005 after Hurricane Katrina, the Commerce Department said. Analysts were expecting July income to stay flat.
Consumer spending, which accounts for about two-thirds of national economic activity, rose 0.2 percent, as expected, the slimmest gain since February, after gaining 0.6 percent in June. However, inflation-adjusted spending dropped by 0.4 percent, the sharpest slide in four years.
Inflation, as measured by the year-over-year rise in the personal consumption expenditures index, rose 4.5 percent, the steepest since February 1991, the government said. When volatile food and energy costs were stripped out, the core PCE rose 2.4 percent, the biggest since February 2007.
-end
As you can see, spending fell off the cliff in July as the 168 billion stimulus pkg given to usa citizens wore off. Personal income fell by .7 percent the sharpest decline in other 2 years and that event was Hurricane Katrina. Consumer spending rose only by .2% percent the slimmest gain since Feb. However if you adjust inflation spending dropped by .4%..the sharpest slide in 4 years.
The economy in the usa is in serious trouble.
The Dow did not like the news and it tanked by 171 points.
Then came news from the private firm the ECRI:
G auge of yearly US economic growth at fresh 28-yr low-ECRI
NEW YORK, Aug 29 (Reuters) - A measure of future U.S. economic growth fell to a more than five-year low and its annualized growth rate hit a fresh 28-year low, sign that a business cycle recovery may not happen in the near future, a research group said on Friday.
The Economic Cycle Research Institute, a New York-based independent forecasting group, said its Weekly Leading Index fell to 125.5 in the week to Aug. 22 from 125.8 in the previous period, revised from 125.9.
Its annualized growth fell to negative 11.8 percent to match its lowest mark since the week to June 13, 1980. The previous week this gauge was at minus 11.5 percent, revised from minus 11.4 percent.
The index declined due to slower money supply growth and lower stock prices, its fall partly offset by lower interest rates and jobless claims, said Lakshman Achuthan, managing director at ECRI, told Reuters.
"With growth in the forward-looking WLI falling to a fresh 28-year low, prospects for a business cycle recovery remain bleak."
-END-
Future usa economic growth looks dismal and it fell to a more than 5 year low.
The news out of England is simply staggering!!
We had two important people stand up and gave interviews on the deteriorating conditions in England.
First, we have David Blanchflower, a member of Mervyn King’s Monetary team. Normally, before the monetary team meets there is silence and then a decision is made by the team.
Blanchflower decided to bolt from the pack and state that 2 million Englishers are going to be unemployed. He predicted that 330,000 more soles will lose their jobs in the next few months.
I have highlighted the section for you:
England…
Bill,
The BBC's flagship late night news programme Newsnight just ran a report (thursday night) that one of the Bank of England's MPC members(Monetary Policy Committee, which sets the UK's interest rates), David Blanchflower, has taken the apparently rather unprecedented step to 'break ranks' and go public, in a Reuters interview on thursday, with a prediction of two million unemployed by Xmas (currently at about 1.67mn*) and effectively called Britain on the verge of a deep slump if the BoE doesn't cut rates drastically:
http://uk.reuters.com/article/businessNews/idUKLAC00291720080828?pageNumber=1&virtualBrandChannel=10174
Nothing however beats the next piece: the Chancellor of the Exchequer, decided to give an interview and he dropped the bombshell that the English economy is in turmoil. He also predicted that 2 million Britishers will be unemployed and get this: he stated that homes will fall by 30%.
In essence, he is saying that the British banks will fail because their collateral will be insufficient to cover the values of loans.
Here is the highlighted section for you to read;
Hi Bill,
The Chancellor of the Exchequer has dropped a bombshell by giving the interview covered in the link below. He is calling it the worst down turn for 60 years which sounds like the worst since WW2. Politically this is quite likely to cost his job and will scupper the government's attempts to persuade us that things are getting better.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2008/aug/30/economy.alistairdarling
Hope you have a great weekend.
Best wishes,
Bob
I urge everyone to go to www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2008/aug/30/economy.alistairdarling for the interview.
During the week we have seen Spain borrow a record level from the ECB as they cobble their toxic non occupied commercial properties and hand them over to the ECB for fresh notes.
We are witnessing a huge deluge of loans initiated by central banks throughout the world. In all 100 billion dollars of loans are coming in every week and no loans between banks.
The libor rates are still high and yet they are still not reflective of the true rate. It should be 2 full percentage points higher.
Banks will not lend to each other because they know they are broke.
The epicentre of this mess is still the usa. We are now entering Sept and this is the month for the Alt a’s and the ARMs to be in full bloom. Expect banks to report warnings to earnings this month as the quarter ends on Sept 30.08. Expect 3 rd quarter earnings to be worse than 2nd quarter etc.
In all the entire losses from the banks will probably be in excess of 2 trillion dollars. The deleveraging effect of these losses will collapse the credit balloon and send the world into turmoil. Willie states that the deleveraging is 60 to 1. Even at 10 to one, the entire credit system collapses.
As for the precious metals we are witnessing a huge disparity in price and scarcity.
The major refiner in SAfrica who is responsible for the making of the gold blanks and the marketing and sale of Krugerrands, announced that it is out of coins. They stated that a Swiss order for 5000 coins totally obliterated their inventory.
The refiner has over the last 40 years averaged 1.1 million oz of Krugerrands each year or 5700 oz per day. It is hard to imagine that they keep only 1 days worth of inventory for the worlds most collectible investment gold coin.
Ted Butler is going to release a paper on Monday and I will forward that to you.
I am going on a holiday and I will not be reporting. However my No 2 son on occasion will report and my No 4 son will put relevant articles from GATA on our website.
I will report on Butlers paper on Monday.
Harvey.